Незамеченный вклад в теорию демографического перехода
Аннотация
Живший во Франции русский эмигрант, бывший приват-доцент Петроградского университета Александр Кулишер (1890-1942) был одним из первопроходцев теории демографического перехода, однако его вклад в развитие этой теории остался почти незамеченным и явно недооцененным. В статье излагается научная биография А.М. Кулишера и анализируются его взгляды на демографический переход (демографическую революцию), нашедшие отражение в публикациях А.М. Кулишера первой половины 1930-х годов на немецком и французском языках. В приложении к настоящей статье приводятся (на языке оригинала и в русском переводе) две забытые публикации А.М. Кулишера, в которых отражено его видение демографического перехода.
Скачивания
Литература
Administrativnyye reformy v Rossii: istoriya i sovremennost' [Administrative reforms in Russia: History and modernity] (2006) / R.N. Bayguzina, ed. M.: ROSSPEN.
Bashford A. (2007). Nation, empire, globe: the spaces of population debate in the interwar years // Comparative Studies in Society and History. 49(1): 170-201.
Bernstein E. (1922). Sowjet-Rußland als Experiment der Geschichte // Die Glocke. 8/1(7): 180-187.
Bocharova Z.S. (1998). Sovremennaya istoriografiya rossiyskogo zarubezh'ya 1920-1930-kh godov [Contemporary Historiography on the Russian emigré community in the 1920s and the 1930s] // Otechestvennaya istoriya [National history]. №1: 91-102.
Borisov V.A. (1986). Yeshche odna data vozniknoveniya teorii demograficheskoy revolyutsii [Another date of the emergence of the demographic revolution theory] // Sotsiologicheskiye issledovaniya [Sociological studies]. № 3: 209-213. See also: Borisov V.A. Demograficheskaya dezorganizatsiya Rossii: 1897-2007. Izbrannyye demograficheskiye trudy [Demographic disorganization of Russia: 1897-2007. Selected demographic works]. M.: NOTA BENE, 2007: 490-497.
Braudel F. (2006). Material'naya tsivilizatsiya, ekonomika i kapitalizm, XV-XVIII vv. [Civilization and capitalism, 15th–18th centuries]. 2nd ed. Vol. 1. Moscow: Ves' Mir.
Coleman D. (2006a) Migration as a primary force in human population processes // Caselli G., J. Vallin, G. J. Wunsch; [et al.]. Demography: analysis and synthesis. Vol. 3. Amsterdam [etc.]: Elsevier: 19-40.
Coleman D. (2006b). Immigration and ethnic change in low-fertility countries: A third demographic transition // Population and Development Review. 32(3): 401–446.
Dahl S. (1936). Den engelska parlamentarismens kärnpunkt // Statsvetenskaplig Tidskrift för Politik, Statistik, Ekonomi. 39(2): 166-168.
Delo (1907). Imperatorskogo SPb. Universiteta o studente Aleksandre Mikhayloviche Kulishere [The records of the Imperial St. Petersburg University about student Alexander M. Kulischer] // TsGIA St. Petersburg. Fond [Collection] 14. Opis’ [Inventory] 3. Delo [File] 50969.
Doykov Yu.V. (2009). Pitirim Sorokin. Chelovek vne sezona. Biografiya [Man out of season. Biography] T. 2. Arkhangelsk. URL: http://doykov.com/tag/pitirim-sorokin/ (accessed: 25.11.2015).
Golosenko I.A., N.I. Serbenko (1999). Petrazhitskiy Lev Iosifovich [Petrazycki Leon I.] // Sotsiologi Rossii i SNG XIX-XX vv. Biobibliograficheskiy spravochnik [Russian and CIS Sociologists of the XIX-XX centuries. Bibliographic reference book] / Redkol. (Editoral board): Zh.T. Toshchenko et al. M: Editorial URSS: 232-233.
Gordon M.K. (1949). [Review of] Europe on the move. War and population changes, 1917–47 by Eugene M. Kulischer // Russian Review. 8(1): 87–88.
Gurvitch G.D. (1942). Pamyati professora A.M. Kulishera [In memory of Professor A.M. Kulisher] // Novyy zhurnal [New Journal]. №2: 374-375.
Hessen S.I. (2011). Sovremennaya demokratiya [Modern democracy] // Kantovskiy sbornik [Kant collection]. №3: 93-97.
Hoffmann-Nowotny H.-J. (2000). Demography and sociology // Position of demography among other disciplines / Z. Pavlik, ed. Department of Demography and Geodemography, Charles University. Prague: 73-79.
Khomenko A. (1925). Do pitannya pro suchasniy ríven' zagal'noï smertností na Ukraïní [To the matter on general mortality level in Ukraine]. Kharkov: TsSU URSR.
Khomenko A. (1980). K voprosu ob urovne obshchey smertnosti na Ukraine [To the matter on general mortality level in Ukraine] // Khomenko A.P. Sem'ya i vosproizvodstvo naseleniya (Izbrannyye proizvedeniya) [Family and population reproduction (Selected Works)] / V.S. Steshenko, ed. M.: Statistika: 96-119.
Kirk D. (1944). Population changes and the postwar world // American Sociological Review. 9(1): 28-35.
Kula W. (1950). Histoire des Institutions : Époque contemporaine // IXe Congrès international des sciences historiques : Rapports. Vol. 1. Paris : Armand Colin : 472-503.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1915). Avtonomiya Irlandii: otdel'nyy ottisk iz zhurnala [Autonomy of Ireland: offprint from the journal] «Yuridicheskiy Vestnik» 1914, VI (II) and 1915, IX (I). M.: Print shop G. Lissner and D. Sovko.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1921). Das Wesen des Sowjetstaates. Berlin: Verlag für Politik und Wirtschaft.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1923). Lord Beaconsfield, 1804-1832. Berlin: Rimon (published in separate editions in Hebrew and Yiddish).
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1925). P.G. Vinogradov // Posledniye novosti [Latest News]. Paris, 1925. December 22: 2.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1927). // Postoyannoye [The permanent] // Posledniye novosti [Latest News]. Paris, 1927. November 6: 3.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1927a). Contribution to discussion on optimum population and food supply // Proceedings of the World Population Conference / M. Sanger, ed. London: Edward Arnold: 102-103.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1927b). Some aspects of the migration problem // Proceedings of the World Population Conference / M. Sanger, ed. London: Edward Arnold: 305-309.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1928). Les guerres et les migrations // VIe Congrès international des sciences historiques. Résumés des communications présentées au Congrès. Oslo : 29-30.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1932). Les quatre constitutions de l’Angleterre // Archives de philosophie du droit et de sociologie juridique. 2(3-4) : 480-529.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1933). Le cycle de population dans les pays modernes // VIIe Congrès international des sciences historiques. Résumés des communications présentées au Congrès. Vol. II. Varsovie : 354-355 (see Appendix to this article).
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1934a). La multiplicité des sources, en droit constitutionnel // Le Problème des Sources du Droit Positif. Annuaire de l'Institut international de philosophie du droit et de sociologie juridique, 1934-1935. Paris : 209-227.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1934b). [Review of] A. Landry. “La Révolution démographique. Études et essais sur les problèmes de la population”. Paris : Libr. du Recueil Sirey. 1934, 230 p. // Archives de philosophie du droit et de sociologie juridique. 1934. 4(1-2) : 257-259 (see Appendix to this article).
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (1935). La Démocratie anglaise et le droit de dissolution // L'Année politique française et étrangère. 10(2): 97-130.
Kulischer A.M. (Kulisher, Koulicher, Koulisher) (2014). Teoriya dvizheniya narodov i grazhdanskaya voyna v Rossii (translated from French) [The theory of the movement of peoples and the civil war in Russia. Original title: La théorie des mouvements des peuples et la guerre civile en Russie] / Preface and comments by M. Tolts // Demograficheskoye obozreniye [Demographic Review]. №3: 158-173. URL: http://demreview.hse.ru/2014--3/143751896.html (accessed: 25.11.2015).
Kulischer A.M., Е.M. Kulischer (1932). Kriegs- und Wanderzüge. Weltgeschichte als Völkerbewegung. Berlin ‒ Leipzig: Walter de Gruyter.
Kulischer I.M. (2012). Istoriya ekonomicheskogo byta Zapadnoy Yevropy [A history of economic life in Western Europe]. 10th ed. Chelyabinsk: Sotsium.
Kulischer E.M. (1928). Die Richtungen der Völkerbewegungen // VIe Congrès international des sciences historiques. Résumés des communications présentées au Congrès. Oslo: 30-33.
Kulischer E.M. (1948). Europe on the move: War and population changes, 1917-1947. New York: Columbia University Press.
Kulischer M.I. (1887). Ocherki sravnitel'noy etnografii i kul'tury [Essays on comparative ethnography and culture]. St. Petersburg: Print shop I.N. Skorokhodov.
Landry A. (1909). Les trois théories principales de la population // Scientia. 6(11) : 3-29.
Landry A. (1933). La révolution démographique // Economic essays in honour of Gustav Cassel. London: George Allen & Unwin, 1933: 357-367.
Landry A. (1934). La révolution démographique. Études et essais sur les problèmes de la population. Paris : Librairie du Recueil Sirey.
Landry A. (1982). La révolution démographique. Études et essais sur les problèmes de la population. Paris: INED.
Matiyeva A.Kh. (2008). Biblioteka M.M. Kovalevskogo v fonde Otdela redkikh knig i rukopisey Nauchnoy biblioteki MGU (Okonchaniye) [Library of M.M. Kovalevsky in the fund of the Department of rare books and manuscripts of Moscow university science library (The end)] // UNIVERSITATES. Nauka i prosveshcheniye [Science and education]. №1: 50-59.
Milyukov P. (2015). Novoye ob’yasneniye khoda vsemirnoy istorii / Predisloviye, podgotovka teksta i kommentarii M. Tol'tsa [New explanation of the course of World history / Introduction, preparation of the text and commentary of M. Tolts] // Demograficheskoye obozreniye (Demographic Review). №2: 106-120. URL: http://demreview.hse.ru/2015--2/167985104.html (accessed: 25.11.2015).
Pavlik Z. (1981). Zákonitosti vyvoje demografických systému // AUC Geographica. № 1: 3-31.
Perepiska V.A. Borisova s Leonom Rabinovichem-Radzinovichem i A. Shubrtovoy [Correspondence of V.A. Borisov with Leon Rabinovich-Radzinovich and A. Shubrtova] (2007) // V.A. Borisov. Demograficheskaya dezorganizatsiya Rossii: 1897-2007. Izbrannyye demograficheskiye trudy [Demographic disorganization of Russia: 1897-2007. Selected demographic works]. M.: NOTA BENE: 498-502.
Rabinowicz L. (1929). Le problème de la population en France précèdé d'une histoire générale de la population. Étude de sociologie de la population. Paris: Marcel Rivière.
Rabkin L. (2015). Anti-Semitism // Encyclopedia of the Jazz Age: from the end of World War I to the Great Crash / J. Ciment, ed. London – New York: Routledge: 67-68.
Russkiy Berlin [Russian Berlin] (2003) / / Sost., predisl. i personalii V.V. Sorokina. [Compilation, foreword and personalities: V.V. Sorokina]. M.: Moscow University.
Sauvy A. (1963). Malthus et les deux Marx. Paris: Denoël.
Serkov A.I. (2001). Russkoye masonstvo. 1731-2000 [Russian Freemasonry. 1731-2000] // Entsiklopedicheskiy slovar' [Encyclopaedic dictionary]. Moscow: ROSSPEN.
Shul'govskiy N.N., compiler (1910). Kruzhok filosofii prava professora L.I. Petrazhitskogo PRI spb. universitete za desyat' let sushchestvovaniya [A circle of the professor of the philosophy of law L.I. Petrazycki at St. Petersburg University for ten years of existence]. St. Petersburg: Pravo.
Simpson J.H. (1939). The Refugee problem: report of a survey. London – New York: Oxford University Press.
Sorokina M.Yu. (2003). Krugi zhizni Nikolaya Martinovicha - uchenogo, diplomata, emigranta [Nicholay Martinovich circles of life - scientist, diplomat, expat] // / Repressirovannyye etnografy: vyp. 2 [Repressed ethnographers: issue 2] / Sost. i otv. red. [Compilation and editing] D.D. Tumarkin. Moscow: Vost. lit.: 347-374.
Subrtova A. (1984). Teorie demografické revoluce: prispevek ke genezi // Demografie. 36(3): 193-199.
Szreter S. (1993). The idea of demographic transition and the study of fertility change: a critical intellectual history // Population and Development Review. 19(4): 659-701.
Thompson W.S. (1929). Population // American Journal of Sociology. 34(6): 959-975.
Tolts M. (2014). Vklad sem'i Kulisherov v mirovuyu migratsiologiyu [Kulisher family contribution to the world migration studies] // Demoscope Weekly. №603-604. URL: http://demoscope.ru/weekly/2014/0603/nauka04.php (accessed: 25.11.2015).
Tolts M. (2015a). Avtor termina «peremeshchennyye litsa»: Yevgeniy Mikhaylovich Kulisher [The originator of the term “displaced persons”: Eugene M. Kulischer] (1881-1956) // Demoscope Weekly. № 655-656. URL: http://demoscope.ru/weekly/2015/0655/nauka05.php (accessed: 25.11.2015).
Tolts M. (2015b). Zabytyy entsiklopedist: Mikhail Ignat'yevich Kulisher [A forgotten polymath: Mikhail I. Kulischer] (1847-1919) // Yevreyskaya Starina [Jewish Antiquity]. №2. URL: http://berkovich-zametki.com/Starina0.php?srce=85 (accessed: 25.11.2015).
Vengerov S.A. (1919). Na venskom literaturnom kongresse 1881 goda [At the Vienna literary Congress 1881] // Vengerov S.A. Sobraniye sochineniy [Collected Works]. [V 5 t. (5 volumes)]. 2nd ed. Vol. 4. Petrogradg : Svetoch: 103-150.
Vinogradov P.G. (2014). Ocherki po teorii prava [Essays on the theory of law]. 2nd ed. Moscow: LENAND.
Vinogradov S.M. (2003). I.M. Kulisher kak istorik-ekonomist [I.M. Kulisher as a historian and economist] // Russkaya nauka v biograficheskikh ocherkakh [Russian science in the biographical sketches] / E.I. Kolchinsky, I.P. Medvedev, eds. St. Petersburg: Dm. Bulanin: 221-234.
Vremennoye Pravitel'stvo i Uchreditel'noye Sobraniye [Provisional Government and the Constituent Assembly] (1928) // Krasnyy Arkhiv [Red Archives]. №3: 107-141.
